A Man Among Ye #5 Review: An Intriguing Choice

A Man Among Ye #5 takes all the things you love about derring-do adventurers and pours it into a pirate theme with simple, effective entertainment value. With behavior that would surely be considered boorish had it come in a different package, this repositioning of identity brings up interesting questions in an engaging manner.

A Man Among Ye #5 Review: An Intriguing Choice
A Man Among Ye #5 Cover. Credit: Top Cow/Image Comics

Anne Bonny wakes up naked in bed with two professional ladies of the evening, and that sets events in motion. She and her all-female crew of privateers are escorting Lady Jane Castor to something resembling safety after a huge bounty has been issued to bring her home. Ideally, this would mean lying low, but when you're a hard-drinking, womanizing, murder-happy pirate captain who's had to be twice as wild as any other buccaneer on the seas, that's a tall order to fill.

The script by Stephanie Phillips does a fantastic job of making a specific, action-packed protagonist make an impact on this period piece. Like a James Bond, this figure kind of makes waves and a big splash everywhere she goes. Likewise, the artwork from Josh George, John Kalisz, and Troy Peteri makes this time period vibrant and engaging with action scenes and detailed areas of a Caribbean village in 1720.

Identity, however, does come to play. The ship's Black first mate walks around without any questions of her right to do so in a time when freedom of movement for African descendants was hard to acquire. Likewise, if Bonny's actions were performed by a person of the opposite gender, we would all rightly decry the patriarchal negative energies being proliferated. For a woman character to adopt similar behaviors with an all-woman crew, identity requires us to look at this through a more academic lens. These questions, combined with the derring-do adventure, make this book an intriguing choice for fans of tales of high seas historical fiction. RATING: HONORABLE MENTION.

A Man Among Ye #5
By Stephanie Phillips, Josh George
Pirate queen Anne Bonny is back with her crew of lady buccaneers after a harrowing escape from a Caribbean prison! But can they find a safe haven on land or sea after Calico Jack Rackham's betrayal and the governor's promise to hunt down and execute Anne? The second volume of A MAN AMONG YE hits the high seas thanks to writer STEPHANIE PHILLIPS (Harley Quinn) and artist JOSH GEORGE (2000AD Future Shock, Grimm Tales of Terror).

A Man Among Ye #5

A Man Among Ye #5 Review: An Intriguing Choice
Review by Hannibal Tabu

Flipping the script on the traditional pirate captain, Anne Bonny, makes you ask a lot of valid questions between womanizing and sword-swinging action.

Elena Salcedo

Enjoyed this? Please share on social media!

About Hannibal Tabu

Hannibal Tabu is a writer, journalist, DJ, poet and designer living in south Los Angeles with his wife and children. He's a winner of the 2012 Top Cow Talent Hunt, winner of the 2018-2019 Cultural Trailblazer award from the City of Los Angeles Department of Cultural Affairs, his weekly comic book review column THE BUY PILE can be found on iHeartRadio's Nerd-O-Rama podcast, his reviews can be found on BleedingCool.com, and more information can be found at his website, www.hannibaltabu.com. As well, alongside artist Demar Douglas, he will answer the question, "What is False Flag?" http://bit.ly/whatisfalseflag
Comments will load 8 seconds after page. Click here to load them now.